Classic Tomato Sandwich Recipe
Posted in Serious Eats
August 18, 2022

Classic Tomato Sandwich Recipe

Classic tomato sandwich on a cutting board, cut diagonally and stacked
Serious Eats / Amanda Suarez

When I was a kid, my mom would reminisce about her childhood in a tiny farming town on the Eastern Shore of Maryland. One of the memories she’d tell me about year after year, especially in the summer when the tomatoes we would get in 1980s Brooklyn were good but not great, was how there was nothing like plucking a ripe tomato off the vine and eating it out-of-hand like an apple right there in the field, each bite sprinkled with salt and still warm from the sun.

Only when I was older and flew off to Italy to work on farms for a year did I manage to experience the same thing myself, finally understanding just how perfect a perfect tomato could be. Here in the States, there may be no better celebration of that perfection than the classic Southern tomato sandwich. While it’s not quite as minimal a treatment as salt and sun-warmth, it still holds tight to the same basic idea—that a great tomato at the peak of its ripeness needs very little. In this case, it’s just white sandwich bread, mayonnaise, and just enough salt and pepper to make it pop.

Side view of a tomato sandwich
Serious Eats / Amanda Suarez

The preparation is so simple there’s not much to explain. Obviously, this sandwich is only worth making when tomatoes are at their absolute peak. Conventional specimens picked while green, gassed to turn them a vague shade of orange-pink, and intended to survive many days on a produce shelf will not cut it. The bread doesn’t need to be anything fancy, and while one could decide to toast it, it doesn’t really need it: The softness and sweetness of basic white bread is just what you want to soak up tomato juices as they drip and mix with the mayo. As for the mayo, passions can run high, though Duke’s, a Southern brand that’s famously thick and creamy, is the one many swear by.

Actually, given how easy a tomato sandwich is, maybe the next time I find myself in a field surrounded by tomato vines, I’ll be ready not just with salt, but some bread and mayo as well.

Lay sandwich bread on a work surface and spread each slice with a generous layer of mayonnaise. Arrange tomatoes on top of one slice, and sprinkle all over with salt and pepper. Close sandwich, cut on a diagonal through middle, and serve right away with plenty of napkins.

Four Image Collage. Top Left: two pieces of bread covered in mayo. Top Right: Two hands placing tomatoes on bread, viewed from the side. Bottom left: close up of tomatoes with salt and pepper. Bottom Right: Side view of tomato sandwich being cut on the diagonal
Serious Eats / Amanda Suarez

Daniel Gritzer August 18, 2022 at 02:02AM

Comments & Reviews

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *